The Risks and Threats of Diagnosing Diseases with Artificial Intelligence
05/03/2021
|
7 mins to read
|
Share article
Table of Content
- Identifying Threats
- Identifying Vulnerabilities
- Identifying Existing and Planned Controls
- Probability Assessment and Impact Analysis
- Risk Rating
- Identifying Appropriate Controls
- Documenting Results
- Risk Processing
- Evaluation and Monitoring
Company Description: Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare
Company Objective: To ensure that decisions in the healthcare field are increasingly made relying on artificial intelligence, facilitating quicker, safer, and less error-prone decision-making processes by enabling early cancer diagnosis.
Identifying Threats
- I requested my risk management team to identify possible threats.
- I categorized and grouped the responses into threat categories and sent them back to my risk management team for review.
- With the feedback, a list of threats was compiled.
The table below lists the Threat Factor, Threat, Threat Cause, and Preventive Measures. Failure to implement these measures could endanger patient health and lead to severe crises.
Threat Factor | Threat | Threat Cause | Preventive Measure |
---|---|---|---|
Employees | Virus Contagion | High virus contagion and its prevalence in daily life | Arrange for special accommodation in a hotel or residence and stay there until a solution is found. |
Employees | Equipment | Virus Contagion | Work areas should be located within the hotel, and all technological needs and equipment should be available. |
Training | External Training and Mentoring Support | Risk of spreading the virus from mentors and trainers arriving from other countries or cities | Prevent long-distance flights and conduct mentoring or training remotely online during this period. |
Work Environment | Environmental Health and Safety | Developing products in an unhealthy environment can threaten people's health. | Clean the environment between breaks, and ensure employees work with special clothes and masks. |
Threat Factor | Threat | Threat Cause | Preventive Measure |
---|---|---|---|
Technical | New Technology | Misdiagnosis due to transition to unfamiliar technology. | Form a special team for this process with the best software developers and healthcare professionals. |
Sector | Healthcare Sector | Being in the healthcare sector itself is a threat and results may not be 100% reliable. | Form a special team for this process with the best software developers and healthcare professionals. |
Team | Team Spirit | The requirement to stay in the hotel until a solution is found may lead to low morale, which could negatively impact work. | Frequent team motivation and ensuring that the team works closely and all needs are met. |
Patient | Patient's Inexperience | The patient’s inexperience with such a large virus and panic. | Conduct patient information meetings and inquire about their needs. |
Organization | Team Stability | Departure of key individuals from the project before its completion. | Contract these individuals and arrange for someone who can replace them in case of departure. |
Threat Factor | Threat | Threat Cause | Preventive Measure |
---|---|---|---|
Economy | Budget | Insufficient budget | Use funds allocated for risk tolerance and keep detailed records of costs. |
Time | Time Pressure | Conditions requiring employees to finish the product quickly. | Sign a contract considering project costs and duration, and adhere strictly to it. |
Identifying Vulnerabilities
The threats listed above could lead to serious vulnerabilities if no measures are taken:
- We do not have a place for employees to stay. This is a vulnerability.
- If the equipment we need is supplied from outside and enters the work area without being disinfected, we have a vulnerability to virus threats.
- In case we have to receive external mentoring or training, there is a risk of someone entering the premises.
- Failure to clean the environment thoroughly.
- A breakdown in team motivation could disrupt the entire process. This vulnerability must be addressed by maintaining high employee motivation.
- Patients or employees making incorrect decisions due to inexperience and panic.
- Carelessness of individuals in the work area.
- Employees' habits of going out, etc.
These are vulnerabilities that invite the virus. Measures must be taken consciously to maintain high motivation and conduct frequent information meetings to address needs and avoid fear and panic.
Identifying Existing and Planned Controls
- Each employee should have their own room, bed, and cleaning supplies.
- Use of disposable plastic cups.
- In addition to each person's responsibility for their own cleanliness, cleaning staff should work efficiently.
- Regular verification of these practices by the cleaning staff.
- Use of food stored in the freezer, taking additional dietary supplements and vitamins.
- Providing food needs from within rather than from outside.
- Continue online training and mentoring.
Everyone should take equal and high-level precautions. Having a variety of products to meet basic needs will enhance control.
Probability Assessment and Impact Analysis
To reduce probabilities, we should be prepared at all times and take precautions as if we are always at risk of the virus.
The following table shows:
- A very small probability of risk occurring is rated 1.
- A lower probability of risk occurring compared to non-occurrence is rated 2.
- A medium probability of risk occurring is rated 3.
- A high probability of risk occurring is rated 4.
- A nearly certain probability of risk occurring is rated 5.
COST IMPACT PROBABILITY | IMPACT VALUE |
---|---|
Minimal Cost | 1 |
Cost increase < 10% | 2 |
Cost increase < 30% | 3 |
Cost increase < 50% | 4 |
Cost increase < 60% | 5 |
TIME RANGE | COST RANGE PROBABILITY | IMPACT VALUE |
---|---|---|
Time <= 40 | Cost <= 1000₺ | 1 |
Time <= 80 | Cost <= 2500₺ | 2 |
Time <= 100 | Cost <= 4500₺ | 3 |
Time <= 140 | Cost <= 7000₺ | 4 |
Time <= 180 | Cost <= 15000₺ | 5 |
RISK OF OCCURRENCE DURING PROJECT | IMPACT VALUE |
---|---|
71% - 90% | 1 |
51% - 70% | 2 |
30% - 50% | 3 |
10% - 30% | 4 |
<= 10% | 5 |
Risk Rating
Definition of Risk Rating Matrix
The following table is divided into Probability and Impact; risk rating will be based on this table. For high-risk degrees, risk measures must be taken before the project starts. This way, we also prevent risks arising from risks.
IMPACT | VERY SERIOUS (5) | SERIOUS (4) | MEDIUM (3) | LIGHT (2) | VERY LIGHT (1) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 | 25 | 20 | 15 | 10 | 5 |
4 | 20 | 16 | 12 | 8 | 4 |
3 | 15 | 12 | 9 | 6 | 3 |
2 | 10 | 8 | 6 | 4 | 2 |
1 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
Risk Rating Matrix
The Risk Rating Matrix is a 5x5 matrix.
RISK PROBABILITY | VERY SERIOUS (5) | SERIOUS (4) | MEDIUM (3) | LIGHT (2) | VERY LIGHT (1) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 | High Risk | High Risk | Medium Risk | Medium Risk | Low Risk |
4 | High Risk | High Risk | Medium Risk | Medium Risk | Low Risk |
3 | Medium Risk | Medium Risk | Medium Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk |
2 | Medium Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk |
1 | Low Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk | Low Risk |
From the listed results, it has been concluded that 6 risks fall into the highest risk category in terms of their impact on the project regarding duration and cost:
Risk 1: Virus Contagion
Risk 4: New Technology
Risk 5: Healthcare Sector
Risk 6: Patient Inexperience
Risk 9: Budget
Risk 10: Time Pressure
The effects of the risks in the highest risk category have been evaluated in terms of duration and cost.
Identifying Appropriate Controls
Technical Security Controls
- Work continuously in specialized clothing and high-security masks.
- Immediately report to the health team in case of nasal discharge, body aches, or fatigue.
- Regularly measure body temperature.
To ensure our safety, we must implement the above measures. If a situation arises that fails to meet security standards, the following management controls should be applied:
Management Controls
- Employees with nasal discharge, body aches, or fatigue should be quarantined at home.
- Regularly check the condition of these patients and provide updates.
- Continuously monitor the patient to avoid causing panic.
Operational Controls
- Provide the patient with adequate oxygen regularly.
- Health workers should immediately start intervention.
- Blood tests should be conducted by health workers and technical staff.
- Address post-traumatic stress disorder.
Operational controls should be carried out regularly with the best intervention from health workers and technical staff.
Documentation of Results
The following data should be recorded individually:
- How many of our employees became ill during this process?
- How many turned into severe cases?
- How many resulted in death?
- How many recovered?
- How many experienced stress disorders and sought psychological support?
Based on the recorded data, risk control, gap monitoring, impact values, and risk assessment matrix will be updated. This will help us make decisions in a more experienced and data-driven manner, benefiting the solution process. The proposed method will be tested with a sample case, and the results will be discussed. These analysis processes are designed to ensure intensive information exchange. Strategies for identified risks will be monitored throughout the project, and the status of the risk data set will be evaluated with the help of warning mechanisms, providing the opportunity to make necessary interventions. Negative outcomes during the project can be monitored and addressed before they turn into risks. All efforts in this direction will positively influence the project and prevent the emergence of risks. Potential risks in threat elements vary; thus, the importance of classifying risks during the identification phase has emerged.
Risk Processing
The data collected in the Results Documentation section must be analyzed and appropriate actions taken accordingly.
- Classification should be implemented as it will be more effective in evaluating the impact of threat elements on risks.
- Risks evaluated as high should be reflected in the project budget.
- Colleagues and team members close to the ill person in the work environment should be immediately controlled to prevent the spread of the disease.
- Physical contact between the ill person and their relatives should be prohibited.
- All needs of the ill person should be addressed.
- By classifying the collected data in the Results Documentation, a risk map will be created.
Evaluation and Monitoring
Strategies for identified risks should be monitored, and updates to the data, including changes in risk levels, should provide the opportunity to make necessary interventions.
Based on the data collected, decisions should be made whether the situation is worsening or improving by analyzing outcomes related to death, recovery, illness, cost, and time. Regular updates of risk control, gap monitoring, impact values, and risk assessment matrix will enable us to respond quickly to sudden decisions.
We should remain open to new plans and constructive discussions. Regular evaluations and monitoring during each cycle will help prevent risks and overcome the virus.
At the end of this cycle, it should be clearly stated whether the results of our practices are improving or worsening. There must be a success benchmark, and based on this, preventive measures should be taken and the new cycle should begin.
-- All Right Reserved © Yiğit Çakmak